The Labour Party Will Underperform

Soon the British media will be SHOCKED and ASTONISHED that Labour has under-performed expectations in the recent council elections. 

A lot of this shock and astonishment will be at how the polls managed to get it so wrong.

It is not astonishing. The polls almost ALWAYS get it wrong. 

Don't believe me. Check yourself. Google "uk opinion polls (election year)". You'll get wikipedia entries showing the difference between the opinions and the final vote.

If you look through general elections back to and including 1987 you will see that the vote share of the party closest to the center has been overestimated almost EVERY SINGLE TIME.

The one exception to this is 2019 when there was no centrist party perceived as being of the center polling over 10%. 

In most cases it is the Labour party, with its drive to "modernization" that consistently under-performed the polls. The first exception was in 2010, when Labour was perceived as being more left-wing than the Liberal Democrats who were polling well under Nick Clegg-the libdems receiving significantly fewer votes than projected. The second was in 2017 when Corbyn's Labour party-widely and inaccurately labelled as a Marxist-Leninist party*, massive outperformed expectations relative to Teresa May's relatively moderate conservatives. 

Why does this keep happening? Because opinion polls just don't work very well as a method. If people lie about their vote or you don't get a representative sample then you have an unknown amount of error. Despite the pollsters attempting to adjust for this there is no way to compensate for the bias accurately as you never know how much of it exists in any given election. 

The media never really takes the pollsters to task because it mostly suits the agenda of the media to promote parties which are stable and corporatist and do not threaten the power they hold. 

This will never change: there is no real penalty for failure. Journalists and pollsters are rewarded for group-think. I suspect any one who pointed out the above would be quietly pushed out of their job. 

There's a disturbing possibility here also: it suits the establishment to promote parties who won't change anything. The social proof that opinion polls provide must have a psychological influence on the public. I don't think this is the result of a conspiracy: it is just a result of pollsters inability to attract samples from voters who are not like them. However these polls effectively add to the advantages enjoyed by incumbents.


*Corbyn's policies would not have looked out of place in countries like Norway or Finland  which we perceive as fairly moderate-it is the public perception that matters however. 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog